I'll readily admit that Tai Chi doesn't have a macho reputation. You don't find many would-be street fighters aspiring to be a Tai Chi master who can kick butt.
Partly this is due to the familiar photos of people doing Tai Chi in China. They usually look pretty darn old and harmless.
Which is one side of Tai Chi, for sure. But Jet Li's The Tai Chi Master shows another side, along with a more recent movie with the same name.
OK. I haven't seen either film. But I'm three years into thrice weekly Tai Chi classes at Warren Allen's Pacific Martial Arts studio here in Salem. So I'm qualified to talk to guys like me who might have qualms about taking up Tai Chi.
By "guys like me," I mean more than 58 year old men with previous martial arts experience who are aging halfway gracefully, but want to help assure this trend continues. Maybe even more than halfway – 75%, say.
I'm using guys in the modern generic sense, just as the waitress does who comes to take our order, looks at my wife and me, and says "So what do you guys want for dinner?" (I suspect she says the same thing to a table full of women.)
So here, in no particular order, are ten macho and not-so-macho reasons for guys to like Tai Chi.
(1) The older you get, the better. Tai Chi embraces the Chinese respect for old age. The Tai Chi magazine I get regularly features glowing articles about eighty year olds. Try finding that sort of thing in an Ultimate Fighting mixed martial arts publication.
(2) It really is a martial art. I've heard skilled hard style black belts say, "I don't do Tai Chi because it's too damn difficult." Yes, it is, when pursued as a martial art. It's a lot tougher to redirect and control an opponent without punching and kicking. But more effective. Really.
(3) You don't get hurt. A big benefit. Today I ran into a guy I used to play tennis with years ago. He says he gave it up because he got tired of injuries (like tennis elbow). Tai Chi will make you more healthy, not less. When I was into karate I always wondered why this "self defense" activity caused people to get hurt so much.
(4) There's more women involved. Tai Chi is pretty well balanced, male and female wise. Not surprising, given its foundation in Taoist Yin and Yang. So you aren't surrounded by sweaty guys for an hour and a half, which was par for the course in my previous martial arts and tennis days.
(5) You don't sweat. Well, rarely. Mostly Tai Chi is practiced (or "played," in Tai Chi lingo) at slow speed. You'll feel a kind of burn, but not the dripping with perspiration kind. More of the "I didn't know I had that muscle" kind.
(6) The dress code is casual. In my classes, at least. Compared to my Shotokan karate days, it's refreshing to be able to wear whatever the heck you feel like. Shorts. T-shirt. Shoes. Barefoot. Whatever. I like not having to change clothes from street wear, except for my shoes.
(7) Tai Chi-ish t-shirts are cool. The first thing I did, when I started Tai Chi, was go online and find some cool-looking t-shirts to wear in class. I figured that even if I didn't know much Tai Chi, I could look like I did. Yin-yang symbols are a common theme. Dragons too. I like.
(8) It comes with a built-in philosophy. Taoism. Which is so inclusive, you can be a Christian, Jew, Muslim, Hindu, or anything else and also be a Taoist. Does tennis have a profound philosophy attached to it? Does golf? Nope. Tai Chi is great for philosophical types like me. Also, for non-philosophical types.
(9) Tai Chi will make you a better dancer. I've never considered myself much of a dancer. But after taking quite a few tango, nightclub 2-step, and other classes, I'm a lot more confident than I used to be. Tai Chi has helped a lot. You learn the importance of balance, weight differentiation, not thinking too much, and having a good time.
(10) It's fun. Which brings me to the most important reason. Try it. You'll probably like it.
I agree with all you said above. I'm not practicing Tai Chi right now, but Golden Shield Qi Gong instead. Only have so much time in my schedule, so had to choose between. Regardless I think Tai Chi is the bomb, especially if you have a worthy teacher who understands its functional/martial aspects.
Posted by: Bpaul | August 11, 2007 at 11:50 AM
Nice post. I studied Tai Chi for a couple years. It was definitely enjoyable. But I can't say as I'm really all that convinced about point #2. Honestly, I really don't think it's terribly effective, at least not how it's usually practiced---i.e., not getting hurt and not sweating :)
It is fun, though. And there are definitely way more babes than were ever in my karate and arnis classes.
Posted by: Coyote | August 15, 2007 at 01:11 AM
Coyote, I've only learned Tai Chi from my current instructor, who took it up after about twenty years of hard style martial arts experience.
So Warren is quite unique, being able to clearly see martial applications in Tai Chi movements where most other instructors just see the movement, and not the application.
Didn't mention this in the post, but I also go to a class where the martial side of Tai Chi is emphasized. We concentrate on the 48 Form, which is more martial'y (if that's a word) than most other forms.
And on Chinese water boxing, or Liu He Ba Fa, a long intriguing form/system that melds Tai Chi with some other arts. We practice the martial applications and I can promise you that they work.
Sort of a blend of Aikido, Jujitsu, Karate and god knows what else.
Posted by: Brian | August 15, 2007 at 09:40 AM
I'm sure it depends on the teacher. My first taste of Tai Chi and Ba Gua was with a teacher in Arizona. He made you work like a dog. I sweated a lot in that class.
When I moved to Portland I took some Tai Chi at PCC, and it was more geared towards gentle exercise. Both were really enjoyable in different ways. But I guess I didn't really get the martial application from either teacher.
Posted by: Coyote | August 16, 2007 at 08:32 PM
Brian,
Your post has rekindled my martial arts interest which waned about 30 years ago.
I dabbled with a bunch of them including a style called "lo kap bak fat" which was very tai chi-like with some pain-inducing techniques thrown in. I liked it because of the far out sounding name that I could tell my friends, and that I could go and eat pancakes after class with the teacher. This didn't last long, as he returned to China. Too bad. He had an amazing way of communicating effectively without speaking any English.
I'm not so spry anymore and have a good number of malfunctioning body parts (anyone who rides horses enough can tell you how they got mangled by them), so Tai Chi may fill the exercise bill.
In my youth, I had excellent reflexes, and well above average running speed. This got me out of more scrapes than any of the jump spinning back kicks I learned in Ed Parker's Kempo class. I remember standing outside a nightclub on the Sunset strip (Pandora's Box for any nostalgia freaks out there), probably around 1966. I had the look of a long-hair surfer and these "greasers" from the valley cruising by in a '57 chevy with moon wheels decided I should be punished for appearing this way. About eight of them emptied out of the car and started after me. Well, stoned as I was, I was still able to recognize a threat and I took off like a rabbit hurdling the picket fence around the nightclub. In the distance of two city blocks I had gained one block on them and they gave up. I returned to the club later, and one guy, not as quick as me was lying on the ground moaning with crushed nuts and contusions.
How in the hell did I get into all that? All I wanted to ask is what to look for in a Tai Chi teacher as there are plenty of them out there. I hear about yin and yang styles. What's the diff? Does it matter?
Thanks
Posted by: Tucson Bob | August 18, 2007 at 02:57 PM
Tucson Bob, you stimulated me to write another Tai Chi post tonight. See:
http://hinessight.blogs.com/hinessight/2007/08/tai-chi-as-a-ki.html
As I said in the post, the "Yang" Tai Chi style doesn't have anything to do with yin and yang. The Yang family founded that style.
I believe the Chen style is the most martial'y. But the Yang style is the most common in this country. A good instructor (like who I'm learning from) probably will be familiar with several styles.
More important than the style is the familiarity of the instructor with "combat" Tai Chi. I talked about this some in today's post.
If you're in a fairly large city, you should be able to find an instructor who can teach Tai Chi from both aspects: exercise and martial art. Give it a try. I like you'd like it.
Posted by: Brian | August 18, 2007 at 09:40 PM
Coyote - where in Arizona? I found this blog because I'm looking for a good Chen style instructor in the Phoenix area, and I can't find anything!
I'm interested in the martial aspect today, and the health aspect 10 years from now :D
Posted by: icey | September 07, 2007 at 09:42 PM
what's wrong with old and harmless?
Posted by: poetryman69 | December 24, 2007 at 06:14 PM
I agree with all you said above. I'm not practicing Tai Chi right now, but I like tai chi video's. on our website https://www.right2fight.in many people searches and ask me many time sir teach tai chi but i like only karate.
Posted by: Dushyant saini | September 13, 2020 at 11:26 PM