« Between Gurdjieff and Zen, I much prefer Zen | Main | Here's my Christmas letter and blog post about not liking the holiday season »

December 23, 2023


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Hi Brian:

Another beautiful post, and perfect for Christmas Eve. Here is where you, I, Ospensky and Gurdjieff (and I would claim the RSSB Masters, (particularly about meditation practice) agree:

Every religion becomes whatever the practitioner interprets it as, both in practice, experience and meaning. And if they proceed, they make adaptations to it that they can live with and which work for them to generate something like progress. There are a whole series of personal decisions, personal habits, and personal interpretations that intervene. And you get a very personalized system of belief and behavior. It's unavoidable. The book is only complete when it finds completion in you.

And actually, you are writing your own version of the book.

When you look at so much Biblical interpretation, different schools within Christianity, Islam and Judaism (ostensibly all about the identical version of God) they become different versions of God, different beliefs.

And looking in the hearts of human beings, the number of beliefs multiply, each with their own take.

It isn't a matter of finally making a decision to go your own way. You were always doing that.

Whatever way you go is your own way. You chose it. You can say you were forced, manipulated, you can blame anyone you like. We are, after all, influenced by the company we keep. And we are not fully aware of what is going on. So when we become more aware, or we simply develop a different point of view in retrospect, it's still us. We are not much less blind than we were.

How do we know we aren't being led down instead of up? And just making excuses for it?

But in all events, whether up or down, we do what we personally have chosen to do.

We leave a system of belief and adapt it, even unconsciously, daily. Everyone who claims to be of one school or another does this, whether they know it or not. Everyone creates their own religion.

Once you understand and see this, then it becomes natural, not unique at all, to simply do a better job, a more purposeful, more intentional job, of constructing the set of beliefs and practices that work for you, because we are all doing this already.

And doing so means we are paying attention to these things, trying to refine our own discrimination, our own skill and understanding. These are built into us, the natural desire to learn and improve.

It's all good, and it's happening in everyone, and we do better recognizing, accepting and putting thought and energy into creating that higher, more natural standard for our development, and working to live up to it.

Ouspensky seems to have picked up his strange cosmogeny from Gurdjieff, who made them up. Beelzebub's Tales to his Grandson is full of this stuff, such as that the moon is inhabited by ant people.

Some of his followers thought G was simply writing tongue in cheek. Others felt he was delusional. Others were agnostic. Others defended G's notions as being quite in line with science, but that his expression of these scientific truths was obscurely rendered.

Such is the way of evolution in religion. In the drive to the new and better, parts of the past endure as vestigial remnants. Opinions differ as to what's the new and better and to what's to be left behind.

There must be a number of reasons why, at some point, one decides to leave teachings that originally attracted them. A chief reason for the initial attraction is the never-ending search for meaning along with the existential question of ‘who am I’ – the search for identity. A religion, a cult, a community or any teaching and discipline, can provide meaning and purpose – and I guess this search for meaning also goes for the scientific enquiry – it all seems quite natural.

I am inclined to favour the type of teaching that directs you back to yourself, back to the enquirer, back to the original ground from where thought and ideas emerged rather than teachings that provide ready-made frameworks where answers can be found. Teachers of such institutions often hold elevated positions (like Gurdjeiff) demanding reverence. They also demand conformity to their principles and beliefs.

But it is quite difficult to leave what may be almost a family and break away on your own. It is often almost impossible to question their beliefs as such systems use terms and concepts that are basically thought forms (Heaven, God, Satan, soul etc.) that defy questioning.

@ Ron E.
>>But it is quite difficult to leave what may be almost a family and break away on your own. It is often almost impossible to question their beliefs as such systems use terms and concepts that are basically thought forms (Heaven, God, Satan, soul etc.) that defy questioning.<<

It is difficult only because on leaving one again steps into the same trap .. that is ... outsourcing one's persona;l responsibility.

Instead of focusing on the teacher and his teachings, proving then first right and later wrong, one better concentrates on where it all started ... in the mind of the seeker.

In doing so he or she might find out that the motives for following were not correct, the invested effort not enough and the goal was selfish and had nothing to do with the teacher and his teachings.

On realizing these things ...the only thing that might be "painfull" is the leaving behind the good people one came to know.

A Guru considered to be God in human form that's Gurinder Singh Dhilion aka satanic Radha Soami Cult Leader.
Who's been exposed and ripped apart by all for being a con artist Baba who has been lying and Stealing money, land and properties from all who he has been in contact with.
That's about as bent as you can get as a baba who isn't even to be called a decent human let alone a god.

This piece of trash Gurinder Singh Dhilion, Radha Soami Cult has to be binned and throw it out as you enter a New Year make it the one resolution you must definitely stick too

Again trust yourself

@ Trez

Given the things you attribute to him, the meaning and value, you must be consider one of his greatest admires .. YOU are the one that puts him on a pedestals and look up to him as a god .. a negative one ... but still a god.

Gurinder singh dhillon has totally plagiarized the word god. He is an evil, crook , rotten to the core and committing a blasphemy of the highest order hiding behind the image of a benevolent god. People have lost their faith in god because of this evil, khana khootha. Gurinder is nothing but the realization of kaal/ Lucifer/ satan who's aim is to cause suffering of souls for eons in a continuous cycle of birth and death. His meditation is of kaal, and demonic so the only place a soul ends up is back into the hell hole, the belly of the beast.
Gurinder, your days are numbered, your time is up. Face your karma like a man, stop hiding and avoiding your punishment.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)


  • Welcome to the Church of the Churchless. If this is your first visit, click on "About this site--start here" in the Categories section below.
  • HinesSight
    Visit my other weblog, HinesSight, for a broader view of what's happening in the world of your Church unpastor, his wife, and dog.
  • BrianHines.com
    Take a look at my web site, which contains information about a subject of great interest to me: me.
  • Twitter with me
    Join Twitter and follow my tweets about whatever.
  • I Hate Church of the Churchless
    Can't stand this blog? Believe the guy behind it is an idiot? Rant away on our anti-site.