« You have options. In religions. In everything else. | Main | Wear your identity lightly if you value truth »

May 20, 2021

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Very insightful, the bit about constantly updating one's beliefs and one's worldview.

This would follow, I guess, directly from a scientific outlook, whether applied to larger, more formal, research, or to one's day-to-day life. Evidence-based thinking would, I suppose, necessarily entail updating one's thinking as and when the evidence itself is updated.

While at one level this is obvious, trivial even, nevertheless it is a fact that one does see, every day, in others, how this does not hold. Larger picture, people routinely deride science for its constantly updating, constantly changing, theories. Smaller picture, people very often look upon a discussion/disputation of their ideas as a personal affront/attack. One can only shake one's head in exasperation at this kind of thick-headedness.

But it's great that Julia Galef writes about this, and that you highlight it here, because while we are quick to recognize imbecility in others, no doubt we ourselves are guilty of such idiotic closed-mindedness ourselves, in our own lives, except we aren't aware of it. The solution to this is, obviously: self-introspection, self-examination, alertness as far as one's own thinking, all of this leading to, hopefully, (greater) self-awareness.

Great post. Food for thought.

Emerson summed all of this up with admirable brevity long ago, when he said "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds."

-------

I was curious about the context of that quote, and some quick googling produces the entire quote, which goes like this:

“A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds, adored by little statesmen and philosophers and divines. With consistency a great soul has simply nothing to do. He may as well concern himself with his shadow on the wall. Speak what you think now in hard words, and to-morrow speak what to-morrow thinks in hard words again, though it contradict every thing you said to-day.”

1. It is the mark of a mature adult to give up a favored opinion when facts prove otherwise.
2. Reason is a Prostitute who will assume any position for a fee.
3. We learn much more from our mistakes than our successes.
4. It's OK to weep the loss of a friend and sing in joy over a new one. There is no shame in that.

@ "A foolish consistency is the hobgoblin of little minds."

@ 2. Reason is a Prostitute who will assume any position for a fee.


Great stuff, guys. Lol

Really enjoying this series of blog posts inspired by ‘The Scout Mindset’.

Not to be too annoying but I have noticed that GSD is very open to considering other people’s perspectives. Like I said, I’m definitely not all in on Sant Mat but at least it’s not hyper dogmatic. Not anymore…

Update your beliefs often as new information comes in

Along with most people, I don't enjoy finding out I was wrong about something. But it's a heck of a lot better than continuing on in my wrongness, which keeps me from learning a more complete truth about that thing.

Isn't thats so true!!!

Sometimes we can be on the wrong path like the leach riddled GSDs rs cult and we can find it hard to see the "wood from the trees" whilst this perpetrator takes full advantage of our innocence and leaves our soul in such a detrimental scarred state.

The GSD & the rs cult is an App which definitely needs no updating, but a full uninstall !!! Recycle Bin.

So many believe Gurinder Singh Dhillon is god in human form and a saviour. This allows this parasitic virus to bury deep into your belief system. But if you take a step back out of the box, and exam who this person is with a simple Google search, you will realise that this man is a more like a mafia man hiding behind the mask of a perfect saint. Examine your beliefs closely, and dont be a sheep. GSD, your days are numbered you dirty old man.

No one can do anything to you. It is a platitude but it will give you more strength than dwelling on negative thoughts.

"Because I hadn't started at 100%, but more like 90%, it felt comfortable to reduce that probability downward as I learned more and more about RSSB and had meditation experiences that failed to confirm the science of the soul hypothesis."

Just in Baba Ji's last Q&A he told someone that they were being too hard on themselves, which also scatters the mind. When Baba Ji said that, I feel that he's saying that the person was on the very cusp of proving this 'science of the soul'. And that their only blockage was that they were beating themself up. Baba Ji finished by reminding us to not to seek results in meditation.

LIES are most valued by RSSB and GSD. Every aspect of this cult leader and the satanic cult is built on plagerism of other religions and acceptance of all to maximize its net of potential followers, and built on a foundation of lies and deception. The guru who portrays a perfect enlightenment person, is a total HYPOCRITE and doesn't look like he has done a days MEDITATION, given he has over 16 shell companies where he has hand picked head hunted sevadars to run and manage. GSD is far too busy in fraudulent activity and hiding this from the public. His answers to Q and A fall very short of the mark in every single way - it is way better to ask siri or Alexa, or even your cat. These people are desperate for answers and not to be mocked or laughed at amongst the sangat. So you can see TRUTH is where GSD and RssB are NOT.

Most of the world must know of India's crisis at the current moment. Truthfully, the last I read in the news was many RSSB Satsang centers were being donated as medical clinics to help combat covid-19.

https://www.tribuneindia.com/news/punjab/punjab-cm-seeks-support-from-radha-soami-satsang-beas-to-combat-covid-crisis-249964

WooDrop #1

Here you go scouts, new information coming in....

https://www.deanradin.com/recommended-references

Time to update your beliefs.

Dib dib dib, or what have you.

Brian sad to say that we don’t realize that we know nothing we can keep updating all or any of our beliefs but unless we get the answers from within we are and continually will be groping in the darkness.

About RS beliefs, a few thoughts about the mandated vegetarian diet.

1. Gurinder Singh developed diabetes. I may be mistaken, but I think I heard that Charan Singh also had diabetes. If the vegetarian diet is truly natural and good for humans, I don't see how even RS masters can develop a disease that is almost 100% diet-related.

2. I've seen videos of the dera langar where giant vats of vegetable oil are used for cooking. Vegetable oil is a leading cause of diabetes and obesity. India and China are the 2 nations that lead the world in diabetes, and by no coincidence are also the leading users of vegetable oil. And also from dera videos, one can't ignore the increasing size of satsangi physical dimensions.

3. A recent question about the necessity and practicality of veg diet was put to Gurinder, and he responded there was no excuse for satsangis not to eat veg, because "the hippos do it." A human's digestive system has nothing in common with a hippo.

My main point here is that the RS argument for veg diet seems based on faith in karma and not much else. After decades of believing that vegetarianism if not veganism was the optimal human diet, I just no longer believe that anymore.

Well Tendzin,

It is my opinion that there is no God that is interested in what you eat and how you spend your life.

But .... if you want to achieve certain goals, people have found in the past that it is better to live a certain life. Not only in monasteries but also in sports.

What we eat and when etc, just effects our brain, it is that simple.

It has never been said by any mystic school wherever in the world that their ideas about living, included food, is there to make one happy or to prevent this or that disease.

And Diabetes is not only about fat but also about the amount we eat, the starches and the sugars and the capacity of the body to digest them. After all not ALL indians develop Diabetes. If you eat more than you can burn in a day ... welll.

Before man developed the whee, the farming, the raising of cattle, and even the techniques on how to catch larger animals and to consume them they had to eat.

So before man were hunters, farmers etc how could they stay alive? They only could by eating the fruits etc of the trees, things that need no cooking, fire etc.

Do whatever you like.

Um, actually before there were farmers, people were apex predators. Humans primarily ate meat for 2 2 million years before they learned to farm wheat and make chapatis. Also, there's little evidence there is now or ever was anywhere on earth where humans could live on a wild vegan diet.

The RS sects not only teach that vegetarianism is the only moral dietary choice, but they also claim that it's a healthy diet, and far healthier than meat-eating. But if lifelong vegetarian Sant mat gurus are getting diabetes, then I think their claims about veg diet are called into question. "Eating too much" is itself not a cause of diabetes, but eating too many simple carbohydrates is, which is why fairly slim individuals like Gurinder can develop diabetes.

I present all this as relative to the topic of "think for yourself." And speaking for myself, until fairly recently I'd believed since the 70s all the popular beliefs about vegetarianism being the ideal diet. I don't believe them anymore, nor do I even believe the sometimes cited "people are omnivores" line, which kind of skirts the issue. I think now there's no doubt but that animal food is historically and biologically integral to the natural human diet, and that while vegetarianism is certainly possible, it's a sacrifice of one's health for the sake of a moral or spiritual ideal.

For many decades meat eaters defended and still defend a diet largely based on meat, and in part the excuse for the slaughter of innocent creatures.

What all the vegetarians have shown us over the decades is that a balanced vegetarian diet is better.

From the Pritikin diet, shown to reverse heart disease, to the Mayo diet and the Mediterranean diet, increasing plant based foods and making them the foundation in the diet is now accepted as the mainstay of a healthy diet. Not meat.

The current trend has advocated smaller and smaller quantities of meat in the diet, as studies keep showing the disastrous health consequences of eating mostly meat over a prolonged period.

Even the Ahnold says a plant based diet is better.

https://www.livekindly.co/arnold-schwarzenegger-beyond-meat-almond-milk/


Studies of different cultures all show the same thing. The best health, the longest life expectancy is a diet that is not exclusively vegetarian, but mainly vegetarian.

And so much research has demonstrated that diets that are mainly flesh based are the source of a whole host of diseases including cancer.

"If you eat a lot of red and processed meat, it is recommended that you cut down as there is likely to be a link between red and processed meat and bowel cancer."
https://www.nhs.uk/live-well/eat-well/meat-nutrition/


So, balance is always the answer.

You can screw up any diet.

But if you are interested in health without having to murder quite so many innocent creatures a low carb plant based diet with a healthy proportion of raw foods, and some additional sources (you can get B12 from yeast and cheese, etc) will be a very healthy.

Even fasting, once thought a disaster for Health in the west, is now seen, when supervised and limited, as part of a path to restoring health.

Mainstream science is catching up. But of course the meat industry, and people's addictions will have their influence. People still smoke cigarettes, after all.


@ Tenzin

Humans are the only species that have the capacity to RE-create their original habitat, what makes it possible for them to survive in places where they by nature could not.

Strip the human from all his inventions and ask yourself where could the human live ... without fire, tools to cut and to hunt and where the difference between the day an noght temperature is not enough to have means to protect him against that temperature drop.
Just think for yourself.

Then inspect whether the human has those physical qualities that have other species that feed themselves on dead bodies and cadavers.

Then focus on a moment on how to eat raw meat ... you see cooking, fire etc are inventions, inventions that were not there to start with for the human. So I would suggest you go to a butcher ask for say a kg of loin meat of your liking and see if and how you are able to swallow it just only using your hands and if you manage to do so see how it tastes.

As you say ...Tenzin think for yourself

They do not prescribe a particular diet other than that the diet be lacto vegetarian. So it is up to each and every person how they eat.

>>I think now there's no doubt but that animal food is historically and biologically integral to the natural human diet, and that while vegetarianism is certainly possible, it's a sacrifice of one's health for the sake of a moral or spiritual ideal. <<

You are free to think whatever you want and there is no god, that is interested in what you eat but if you want to excel in certain activities you have to adapt a proper diet.

P.S.
Many have devaluated old spiritual practices to siting strait, cushions, walking the markets with pieces of paper that mention E-numbers, and doing this or that communal work for free as service to that community and the benefits they suggest for their mental and physical welfare.... so be it

And Tenzin,

It what cuisine do people eat RAW meat? As far as I know in none. and if they do the raw meat is mechanical cut in such away that the consistency is that of a fruit.

The Inuit do eat raw fish but they can only swallow and digest it because they have developed a special cutting technique. Our tees an molars are not strong enough to cut queer through the raw fibres

A visit to your local butcher or a talk to a chef of an nearby restaurant will inform you about the relation between fibres and the ability to chew them. They will tell you that a wrongly cut meat is chewable as leather..

So what is cooking all about?

Well Tenzin cooking is nothing but an process of giving other wise unpalatable and undigestable food the structure of fruit ....a process by which the fibres are softened and taste is added.

Humans did not start with that knowledge, they developed it by necessity, because their original habitat was changed or they left it.

And it cannot be stressed enough, ...do whatever suits you. You are the only one that is responsible for the use of your body and mind and has to bear the consequences of that use.

If you do not want to meditate, leave it alone. If you want to eat meat do it but please do not find excuses for what you do outside yourself.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Welcome


  • Welcome to the Church of the Churchless. If this is your first visit, click on "About this site--start here" in the Categories section below.
  • HinesSight
    Visit my other weblog, HinesSight, for a broader view of what's happening in the world of your Church unpastor, his wife, and dog.
  • BrianHines.com
    Take a look at my web site, which contains information about a subject of great interest to me: me.
  • Twitter with me
    Join Twitter and follow my tweets about whatever.
  • I Hate Church of the Churchless
    Can't stand this blog? Believe the guy behind it is an idiot? Rant away on our anti-site.