« Golden Rule is a poor guide to morality | Main | An ex-Christian talks about the uselessness of prayer »

May 20, 2019

Comments

Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

Has anyone found out if any of the money made its way into the US? It always struck me as kind of odd that this man who was supposedly coming to USA for satsangs only found 45 minutes to spend with the people whose souls he claimed to be responsible for. I assumed he was just doing business as usual when he came to Chicago, but it'd be funny if he were charged for racketeering or something here, too.

This soo sad...
Why can't they come to agreements... ??
One would say that must be possible..,but who am I ?
I really feel for them.
Actually especially for Malav.
But again..who am I ??
I do not know much about money..happy that i can eat and have a good roof over my head..
My English is not fantastic.
And I never see the people involved..
Altough that I feel for them..
They are my Maharaji's family..
Maharaji was my beloved Master who did so much good in my life..
Again the teachings were to heavy to me..
I am more of a Bhakti type..I often fell over my own feet (spiritually speeking)
Maharaji once said to me ''you are just like my daughter''..
So Nimmi was in my heart my Sister..
I feel for all of them anyway anyhow..
I hope that ..well I do'nt know what hope..
Maybe justice..no matter what..there must come an reasonable good end to all of this.

Just my feelings..now in the moment..

@ s

They are all fraudsters. God dies not mix with Money!

Don’t feel sorry for con men sister. They wouldn’t feel sorry for you!

Regards

A

Hi Arjuna,
You are right ofcourse they do not feel for me..
But the family falling so apart..
What would maharaji Charan Singh had done right now??
I think that he at least would felt terrible.

@ s. Sister

It’s the past let it go and don’t dwell too much on what Maharaji would have done.

It’s a sad state of affairs and for people seeking hope it’s been destroyed. I mean people from non RSSB grounds who seek hope. We all do it’s what being human is. The mind is very powerful and is always thing what if etc. Enjoy every moment of life.

All the best

The story of GSD and his cohorts will forever be a reminder in history of what happens when you mix material greed with spirituality.

Dear Arjuna,
Enjoying every moment of life..thank you yes..
With the ups and downs..life gives also.
I do not ''involve'' myself too much in this story.
It is theirs not mine for sure.
We are mixed bags and sometimes things come up.
I realy feel sorry,but everything has a purpose..
For years I was grown up thinking these people were totaly perfect..
Now we know they are totaly struggeling human beings.
They must/will find their way.

s*

I totally understand how you feel. It’s very sad, especially for the Singh brothers. I’m not sure if Dhillon actually has feelings... not sure if he’s even capable of feeling remorse but if so then I feel sorry for him too.

My advice to GSD is watch Lucifer on Netflix—it will bring you enlightenment. :)

I personally feel that one should not totally & blindly believe in what media projects & says. For all those who have adopted this path....please go and ask the Guru straightforwardly instead of getting carried away by what the media says. All the followers have the right to do that....they have placed their faith on Sant Mat. So why not ask directly & get the doubts cleared. No one knows the true story. So please ask directly.

Ritu Gupta, good luck getting an answer.

Only answer you get will be "what do you think" or believe what you want to believe".

We haven't yet heard a "No, it's false, not true, or Yes, it's true".
Why is that?

Give a good think on that. If you know it to be false, just say so.

Maybe you can ask at the next Q&A and let us know what he says.

Ritu Gupta, someone did ask Gurinder about the financial fraud accusations. See:

https://hinessight.blogs.com/church_of_the_churchless/2019/04/rssb-guru-responds-to-allegations-of-criminality-weirdly.html

This is what the RSSB guru reportedly said. Not very responsive, for sure:

Q: Babaji: what do you have to say about the financial scandal?
A: RSSB has nothing to do with it. In case you want to read we have an article on the website.

Q: In case someone asks what should we say?
A: Tell him my baba was getting bored he needed some excitement and he came with a bang.

Q: Are you sure I say this?
A: Yes, it’s up to you whatever you want to believe.

Q: How come you have been silent on it and made no comments?
A: If I don’t tell you to react then how can I react.

Brian you are again posting something you have no full knowledge on. I was in Singapore in the audience during this Question and answer session and everyone in the audience got the reply they wanted. You were not there and have NO IDEA what actually transpired. And also
This is not the first time he has been asked this it’s been brought up few times in different places as well.
I want to let everyone who comes to this site to listen to Ritu and not merely read what you see here on COC of in the media. Beware of these people posting here as they have an alternate agenda. They are not open minded and only want to prove the Master wrong.

Anon, the person who sent me the Q&A "transcript" also was at the Singapore meeting. Are you saying this person is mistaken? Do you have a different version of this particular Q&A? If so share it. If not, stop with the ridiculous accusation that because I wasn't there I don't know what happened.

Someone who was there told me what happened. This is called reporting. Take a look at a newspaper. You're learning about things that you weren't there to see yourself.

Difference is Anon was there, Brian Spence and Jesse were not. So by defacto contrast the person who has a direct personal experience is far more credible in their judgment and perception than anyone operates via 3rd person reporting, especially if the 3rd person also has some axe to grind in presenting the 'report' for ulterior motivation of misplaced 'interest'.

Brian the person who sent you the transcript was NOT at the Singapore meeting. He has received this as a forward and is forwarding it to you. I know who wrote this Transcript and yes this is not written the exact way it happened. The person who “reported” this to you was not there either. Again you don’t know much but pretend to act like this is classified information being sent to you. Please be better informed before you start writing blogs about topics being “reported” to you.

It would be best for anyone who has a sincere respect for honesty to follow through with the lady Gupta's advice and confront the 'alleged' perpetrator of said crimes directly in person. Then they'll at least get an answer which either satisfy their 'curiosity' or vilification of their accusations, or not.

Otherwise it remains hearsay, subject to assumptions and personal projection of preconceived opinion.

The fact is we don't know who was there.

Whom should we believe?

But when facts are present and summarily dismissed, then the witness is not objective. They have a relationship with the accused.

The reader will have to make up their own mind. And I suggest that an objective person would want that.

Anon
I have a very hard time believing that's your name.

I get that there are a lot of Susans and Johns in this world.

But everywhere I look on the internet I find Anon.

And here is the really strange thing.

I've never ever met anyone face to face with that name!

I hope you don't mind my saying this, but I'm suspicious about what you write because Anon isn't a real name.

So when you start like that, really, what are we to think of what you write?

Spence you can be suspicious about anything you want it doesn’t change the fact that I’m writing what I heard about which doesn’t match what is reported here. I have the liberty to use my real name or go anonymous and I choose the later.

@Ilahamni,

Is that an Indian name?

Anyway, are you saying we should go to a meeting or Satsang and ask GSD about his financial woes? Personally I really don’t care about his personal finances... or his financial woes. It’s just simply a forum to debate his integrity as far as spirituality goes. Even if he were able to truly convince me that he is completely honest in all his financial dealings (which, again, I couldn’t care less about) I would still be convinced that he’s Lord of Hell (just based on my personal experiences with him).

But ‘Lucifer’ has taught me its all about self forgiveness... so in the end the only thing that matters is self love and Truth.

I learned more from that stupid Netflix series than I ever did from Sant Mat.

Sonya I’m glad you found what you needed to find in Netflix. Great for you. Why you so concerned about Master then? You didn’t have a good experience as you so clearly keep writing here so then leave it leave the path and go. Why the constant bashing? Do you make yourself feel better or superior somehow by constantly doing this? You don’t see a problem with your regular need to take pot shots at him?
And by the way he never forced you to listen to him or attend his talk...you did this out of your OWN choice.

Anon, your credibility is zero until you provide your real name and your own description of how Gurinder answered the question about the financial fraud allegations.

I have an email message from someone who provided their genuine name and email address to me, along with the following description of what was said in Singapore. If you disagree with this description, please email me with your alternative description: [email protected]

I trust people who are willing to reveal who they are to me, even if they want to publicly remain anonymous, more than someone like you who hides behind "Anon." How do I know you are credible? Here's the description I was given:

Q: Babaji: what do you have to say about the financial scandal?
A: RSSB has nothing to do with it. In case you want to read we have an article on the website.

Q: In case someone asks what should we say?
A: Tell him my baba was getting bored he needed some excitement and he came with a bang.

Q: Are you sure I say this?
A: Yes, it’s up to you whatever you want to believe.

Q: How come you have been silent on it and made no comments?
A: If I don’t tell you to react then how can I react.

Brian like I said I don’t care if you think I’m crediible or not. I don’t need to email you as well as I’m messaging here itself which is for everyone to read instead of a private email between the 2 of us.
I will stick with anon as my identity on this blog because Giving out my real name makes no difference on what was said
In the question and answer session In Singapore. If you want answers from the master then attend the session and you will hear him reply to this and it will be your first hand experience NOT what someone understood of what was said and later on forwarded to many people which after that was emailed to you by someone who was no where close to Singapore. I was there in the audience and the person who sent you this forward was not and neither were you so you have no idea what answers were given and in what context. What was “reported” to you is not accurate just like all the other reports you keep referring to. End of
Story

Anon,
Have you read the letters posted here? About the isue's?
Also between Malvinder and Babaji?
One can see clearly that they are in trouble.
Babaji involved..
Malvinder is frightened even now even because of Dera sewadars..
He,they are in trouble..

An On
Thank you for your most interesting posts here on this blog.
I see that you have carefully overlooked the obvious to the obfuscation of the real points being made here. I admire how a multi faceted blog can be reduced to a singular non sequitur by your dexterity in semantics.
Please keep posting. You have coloured me beautiful .
Those who seek the Truth
Those who see the Truth
Whose Truth

Anon, any update on Ishwar's answer to your follow up question?

"And by the way he never forced you to listen to him or attend his talk...you did this out of your OWN choice."

Nobody is forcing you satsangis to read this blog or our comments either. Time to move on and refrain from your attempt to dictate what we talk about, Anon. We're gonna continue criticizing "master" and his creepy followers.

Anon, you, like GSD, have refused to actually answer the question. What did he say in response to the questions?

You've been asked multiple times here and you deflect. So if you really were there, and I guess out of the hundreds (maybe thousands?), you can tell who was there and who wasn't, then you can enlighten all of us what his answers were? Or maybe you weren't really there wither.

That's why you can't tell us.

Hi seeker no I didn’t hear back from Ishwar Puri on the follow up. I can try to reach out again and see if he responds this time. Will keep you updated. Thanks

Hi Anon
Please share what you remember, since you say you were there.

Add your witness to the other.

"don't shout at the darkness. Light a candle."

@ Sonya

You do realise that Lucifer on Netflix is fictional😋

Like I said if you want answers attend the session and you will get it. All of us that were there got our answers. This blog is not the place to get answers or to write about what transpired. And actually for once Jesse is right no one forces us to come here and I did come here to read on Baba Faqir Chand as it was interesting since David was there with him in person but now that conversation is over I’m out of here. This space is not for me. Blessings to all.

Anon, I was curious about where you are commenting from. Turns out, Palo Alto, California.

Since you aren't able to describe what happened at the Singapore meeting, seems like there's a good chance you weren't at that meeting. Also, it's decidedly possible that you are the same person as "Jen from Austin Texas," who also is from Palo Alto but deceives about that.

Kind of amazing how supposedly "spiritual" people are willing to be so loose with the truth. Makes me glad that I'm a truth-loving atheist.

Good catch Brian Ji!

Hi Anon
You wrote
"All of us that were there got our answers...."

And earlier you wrote
" I was there in the audience and the person who sent you this forward was not..."

But in another place you wrote
"I’m writing what I heard about which doesn’t match what is reported here."

In the first two you claim first person status. But in this earlier quote you claim to have only heard about the event, second or third hand.

So please confirm which it is. Remember that Baba Ji sees you and knows if you are telling the truth.

Take advantage in your reply to be honest, if only for His sake, please. And if course like all events this will be part of your development.

Don't worry. Brian Ji loves the truth. All is forgiven when anyone here tells the truth, however painful that may be.

Aw shame than Anon is out of here
I thought he would go on an on an on

Brian surprising to me that you write so much about this path and yet you don’t know that you don’t have to be from a local place to attend the meeting locally. It’s open to all. And this particular one was announced prior so that people knew about it. Not the first time I was in the audience. You don’t want to believe me then don’t. The one who forwarded you the email was NOT there and it’s NOT an accurate reporting of what transpired. That’s my point.

Mike that’s funny. Hahahahaha

Anon, I look forward to getting a copy of your airline ticket to Singapore, your real name, and your description of how Gurinder Singh Dhillon responded to the question about financial fraud allegations.

Absent that, there's no reason for me, or anyone else, to believe you rather than the person who gave me their genuine name and shared what happened at the Singapore meeting.

Hi Arjuna,

Yes! 😂 I know he’s fictional—it’s all fictional but there’s a very good moral to the series that shows how ridiculous and destructive religion and dogma can be. :)

It’s just a beautiful story where the Devil learns to love himself. It represents to “devil” in all of us that sits on our shoulders judging us. The devil is just our minds. He’s not real. We make him real if we believe in him.

Lucifer is just really fun. Especially the last/latest season and had an awesome Season finale.

Anon,

You keep saying the same thing over and over and so do I... What’s the difference?

Don’t be too offended by the “Lord of Hell” statement. If you watched the most recent season finale of Lucifer you’d see it’s not really an insult.

OK, I’ll TRY not to keep talking about Mr. Morningstar.

:)

I also wannabe an enlightened Xer guru hater freedom thinker

Where do I sign up to the elevated club?

Out of 4,000,000 initiated there's 1,2,3,4 and 1/2 enlightened clear sighted free thinkers in here, must be one hell of an eye opener to realize how stupid and gullible they all once were.

Brian sure I will give you my airline ticket. I bought that online so it’s an easy forward to your email. As soon as you provide me with the information that what you reported is true and the person who forwarded this to you provided his information.(I don’t need name as I know just airline ticket just like you ask me) I find it fascinating how you ask me for this but did not get any information from him before reporting it as what happened. It’s because you will report what suits you and your agenda. This is how this blog works. I hope people who read this are aware of this.

"Brian surprising to me that you write so much about this path and yet you don’t know that you don’t have to be from a local place to attend the meeting locally."

Not true' at least for satsangs were the guru was present. I was only allowed to go to Gurinders satsangs in Chicago. Not the Petaluma or the other locations. I still get phone call announcements for those visits sometimes.

"Jesse is right"

As always.

I get tired of being right so often, Anon, but I rarely get tired of hearing from others who finally take the brave step to admitting how right I am. Thanks for finding the courage to embrace the truth.

As for your comment- "Like I said if you want answers attend the session and you will get it" allow me to be right again and tell you that you're utterly incorrect. You will not receive an answer about anything from your baba. His answers are all deflections, regardless of the topic at hand.

IlahamL, all good things are rare. Saying there are 4 million who believe in something isn't a strong case for believing, especially considering that nearly all of those 4 million rebelled against and rejected spiritual paths with more members. There are nearly a billion Hindus and over a billion Christians.

If numbers are relevant, return to your original religion.

Also stop changing your name if you're gonna comment the exact same way with every name. You're probably one if these sad mental cases who pay for VPNs

Anon, you still haven't responded to what GSD said in response to the questions.
You keep replying to the fact that you can prove you were there, but don't say what GSD really said.

Which probably means you don't know, do you? If you haven't responded yet, I doubt you will, because you yourself can't recall.

I believe he's coming to the Pacific Northwest and California this summer. I'm sure he will be asked the same questions. Maybe someone will comment on his responses and you can say that they weren't there, and that you were there, and you still won't be able to give a proper answer.

VPNs???

No I'm just curious about how you became so enlightened to realize guruhood is such a diabolical sham.

You must either have a sixth sense or special illuminated insight to recognize fake gurus (on the outside of course - notwithstanding it's highly unlikely you ever met anyone on the inside).

Assuming your elevated intelligence has such a keen sense of knowing truth from falsehood and your BS radar is obviously far keener than those other poor 4,000,000 suckers who don't have your special gifts.

Fascinating exchange between Anon and the Ring Master

Who is actually the liar and who is the truth-seeker?

The spiritualist or the atheist - get the answer to that one and all else is meaningless.

There was no original religion to rebel against, perhaps for you there might have been. Why I should return to any 'original religion' that died with it's founders is just a dumb kind of concept.

I got to conclude you're just plain dumb because your supposed intelligence is warped by your grandiose blindly duped intellect.

Brian should be commended for his selfless great seva he is doing.

He is the ultimate sevedar doing the guru's tough ask work. By hosting this site he's contributing to keeping all those highly intelligent and scrutinizing analysts of falsified guru worship far from the path.

Their place is here in the hallowed halls of critical thinking.

Most definitely not at any audience with any fake teachers who teach their followers to still their thoughts and concentrate at a point between their shut eyes.

Hi Ilahaml
You wrote
"You must either have a sixth sense or special illuminated insight to recognize fake gurus."

Several hundred millions in fraudulently obtained (stolen) funds somehow finding their way into the pockets of the Guru, their wife and sons can do that too.


Given Anon's reticence I conjecture that whatever Baba Ji said, it did not involve taking even the most minute rice grain of responsibility.

Typical.

Or maybe Baba Ji said some other sarcastic deflection.

Typical.

Or maybe Baba Ji demanded silence and obedience and veiled threats of 'it's your loss if you question pappa.. '

Typical.

You see Anon and Ilahaml, from the above....

We've been to a few meetings too.

Spence
you want it doesn’t change the fact that I’m writing what I heard, about which doesn’t match what is reported here
I added a comma and now perhaps it makes sense to you.
Brother if you want the truth (as you say) you should start with getting off this blog. Like I said I’m outta here. Let’s go 😊

@All...

Just for the record, I’m NOT enlightened. But I do know this world is made up of perception. And no two people agree on absolutely everything. So, sometimes we’re right and sometimes wrong. Some more than others...

Back to my playful sarcastic self so don’t take this devil thing (or religion for that matter) too seriously.

Then again, who am I to tell anyone what to think or do. I often ask myself why I keep reading the comments posted on this blog. And then I realized why. I watch, listen and participate because there are a lot of very interesting characters with very curious viewpoints here. VERY.

OK, if Brian actually posts this comment with Lucifer recap/season 4 preview link I’ll stop talking about him. 😂 😈 https://youtu.be/J_a4UDOw9Rc

I think most of the stories from religions and saints are pretty much allegorical... like children's stories. Lessons to be learned... life is essentially just a series of stories. Take from it what you will...

I'm beginning to understand the way the path of the Guru inflates egos and destroys actual spiritual progress.

By believing the Guru is perfect and never errs, the follower believes they can now claim they are also, in tiny degree, something perfect and priceless. But only so long as they acknowledge the Guru as the absolute perfection. And that in the service to the Master they are also perfect and cannot err.

When the Guru says 'at this level you cannot possibly understand' they teach every follower a new excuse which they can use at any convenient time for any moral transgression.

This is the fastest path to the bottom of the wheel.

What person would give up such wonderful toys that the path provides, though they assure one 's fall from their true natural state.

Only Truth, ugly and magnificent.

Thank you, thank you, thank you Brian Ji.

Welcome to the Kangaroo Court. Talk about hearsay! Babbling away on both sides and its all meaningless especially for the less and not the meaning. I know these words are non-sense meaning but where is the Jury *sigh. So difficult to NOT react...

My favourite quote: "A: If I don’t tell you to react then how can I react." Makes sense huh?!

Jen,
It's strange to not react to loved ones..
To ones you live with and to questions from disciples.
How can one have faith if there is no communication?

One has not to react when people are not good to you ofcourse.
But that is a different cookie.
Between the guru and disciple there has to be a bond of faith in my vieuw.

Actually I meant a bond of trust.
So that is something to work on from'' both sides.''
Babaji could have give trust..to a doubting disciple.

Spence,

Totally agree. It’s not fair to anyone to believe humans can be perfect. It’s not fair to put that expectation on someone either. We’re all flawed... just trying to find our way “home”.

@ s*

How I feel, now that I no longer see myself as a satsangi, is that maybe Gurinder is being more blunt than the previous Masters and he is just being himself, another human being like everyone else. People put these Masters on a pedestal and have too many expectations about them so then they are disappointed. I have never met anyone who is loving to everyone, obviously I have not met a Saint and I wonder do they even exist? Probably not. I even don't care about all this problem of what his business practices are about. If he is doing wrong then he will eventually be found out and punished accordingly.

Cheers to you, hope you can find peace, embrace your life and live it to the best you can is my philosophy now and I even accept my feelings of depression at times, because life ain't easy!

@Jen,

I promise, this isn’t just another one of my cheeky songs. It sums up what happens when one has the courage to question, not afraid to lose what they have held on to as truth for far too long: https://youtu.be/eJmAVBDp0Cs

Jen I agree with some of what you said except for this part-

"People put these Masters on a pedestal and have too many expectations about them so then they are disappointed."

The fact is that he uses the title of Master and literally walks himself onto a pedestal in front of hundreds of thousands of people.

All he would ever have to do is stop showing up and disappear. No more pedestal. No more master.

Maybe the bigger issue is the teachings of Sant Mat. I mean, guru aside, I think it’s just the age old teachings of Sant Mant which don’t feel too saintly. Aside from what GSD does in his secular financial life, the real truth (for me) is that the teachings just don’t resonate. As far as spirituality goes, I’ve recently (VERY recently) learned that it has nothing to do with Gurinder. I just don’t believe in the teachings, that’s all. So what if he and I have had personality clashes. I’m feeling mature enough now to realize that was insignificant and it has nothing to do with the bigger picture. And the bigger picture—the grand scheme of things—the judgements, I just don’t buy it anymore. It’s not like GSD was a self-appointed guru. So my issues aren’t with him. There, no “pot shots”.

Jen and Jesse,
I am ok with that I know for a longer time, they are not perfect.
But still I have a sort of attachment to sangat,it's near my house and I bike trough nature to see my friends.
And do some sewa..it's just nice..
I felt for Babaji in a different way..but his behavier went more ''strange''.
What Jesse says..he is still is on a pedestal.
The teachings are more of advaita read new book ''from self to shabd''
Pitty there is written that ''the master'' is totaly byond body and mind.

I feel that even as friends one react on important things otherwise there can not be a bond.

Hi Sonya,
Idd the teachings do not resonate with me also..actually never did.
I found them scary even.

The new little book has some very good things'' from self to shabd.''(Hector Esponda Dubin)

Nisargadatta and Ramana and Buddha quotes..:0)

The teachings somewhat change more and more.

@Jen My favourite quote: "A: If I don’t tell you to react then how can I react." Makes sense huh?!

No, it does not make sense.

If we're falsely accused of a crime we can't say anything in response to that because it would be 'reacting'. LMAO

Imagine for a moment a fiercly competitive British trading company investor and hard as nails land barron from the 1800's. He enjoyed being the best, and crushing his competition. One of his favorite sayings was, "One must kill something every day!".

Now, ironically, he finds himself reborn into an Indian family whose heritage is Sant Mat. Now they appoint him, type A personality and all, the next guru, because he is the most 'get it done' personality they have ever seen, and thinking this must reflect great Spiritual power.

Welcome to RSSB...

Sonya appreciate the comment without the pot shots. Now we can have a good discussion. I’m just curious which part of the teachings don’t resonate with you? And if so why did you get initiated?

@ Jesse,

Thousands of people, probably millions, give their personal power away to all sorts of religious leaders, pop stars, presidents, and so many other types who people put on a pedestal and worship. Whose fault is it, if some people are so vulnerable as to believe in anything they are told by someone posturing on a stage. Is it because they are desperate and empty and seeking for something else, so who to blame, the actor or the vulnerable person?

.....................

PJ when I quoted what Gurinder supposedly said: "A: If I don’t tell you to react then how can I react." Makes sense huh?!"

I was being sarcastic because the quote does not make sense. Thats why I put "Makes sense huh?!" like saying: "What The?!"

Jen you miss the point. In leftist circles you're what would be called a "victim blamer" though I don't care about that kind of thing.

Yes people are idiots who like being taken advantage of. And yes there are opportunists who are willing to take advantage.

At no point have I or would I solely blame Gangsta Gurinder, but to say others are putting him on a pedestal simply isn't true.

He hires marketers and authors to advertise his sect, invite attendees to huge meetings, has workers build stages and buildings for the sole purpose of providing space for him to talk, and then walks with his own two feet onto a stage in front of them to tell them that he and he alone can save them from hell.

It's not like Gurinder was just sitting at home and a mob formed outside and declared him to be god.

Hi Jesse,

Not victim blaming. Just have a different mindset. Everyone is entitled to believe whatever they want to. I agree with Zen thinking "With our thoughts, we make the world" so its up to each individual as to how they see life. Asking myself now why am I even here on this blog! Cheers bro...

Hi s*

Interesting you bring up the latest RSSB book. I read it a few months back to see how things were now being ‘presented’, and posted a comment on this blog.

From memory and generalising, the book seems to be trying to ‘update’ the teachings, with as you say a more advaitic flavour. However, it confused things imo when the writer started to use the terms soul, consciousness and shabd interchangeably. I thought WTF? But then again maybe its all the same thing, it’s just that dogma even the new kind clouds it all for us.

Best wishes


...what Gurinder supposedly said: "A: If I don’t tell you to react then how can I react." Makes sense huh?!"

Hi Jen,

Seems very Zen-like to me too. After many reads, my best guess is he
was joking to make a point.

His point was to challenge the questioner to look within and use his
own intellect, intuition, or "inner master" for answers. There isn't an
"RSSB for Dummies" manual. Nor do you need to race quivering to
the microphone and pester the Guru with "Whadda we say about
the scandal".

But the questioner doesn't get the joke or the point ("Are you sure we
should tell "em ya were bored and wanted a little excitement")
So GSD says it again: "It's up to you whatever you want to believe".

The questioner is still in the dark ("How come you've been silent and
made no comment") GSD tries a final time: "If I don't tell you to react,
how can I".

In my opinion, GSD is saying we don't have to knee-jerk a response to
every crisis, race for the RSSB manual, go on bended-knee to the
Guru for a "how-to". The point of meditation is to stop looking outside
for a savior, look within yourself, consult the inner master (or your own
mind), draw your own conclusions about the evidence...

Then the questions will fade and the befuddled disciple will be following
the intended mystic path of RSSB instead ot sleepwalking in a cult of
one's own making.

Anon,

The part of the teachings that don’t resonate with me are that God punishes sinners. That we are “guilty” in the eyes of God. Now I believe we punish ourselves and that God doesn’t see any imperfections in what he created. He cannot create imperfection. We create guilt and that guilt causes us to punish ourselves and when we punish ourselves and feel fearful we become the worst versions of ourselves. And that’s when we destroy what’s beautiful. That’s when we destroy others. It warps our perception and we project our own false guilt upon others. It’s a vicious cycle.

Ironically, I decided to get initiated because I thought it would help me get rid of my “guilt”. Instead it only reinforced and compounded my imaginary “guilt” making me a much more fearful person. Fear and hate are just two sides of the same coin. Ask Yoda. :)

Anon,

We could essentially just start and end with this—“Radha Soami” which we translate in English to mean Lord of the Soul. So there was Soami (Lord) the husband, and then his wife Radha (Soul). There you have the husband “lording” over his wife...

Don’t trivialize this. The implications are profound. If there was an Original Sin it was the birth of inequality.

Inequality... and in the most intimate of relationships. I’m sure GSD would say he thinks men and women are equal, but would he say that everyone is equal to him?

Adam and Eve... Lilith and Lucifer. WTF is wrong with this world??? It’s not our stupid karmas. It’s the belief in and acceptance of inequality. Caste, creed, race, blah, blah, blah. Doesn’t even compare to the complacency (especially in India) towards gender inequality.

And I can’t remember if it was you or someone else who said I doubt you’ve never seen anything inside—I’m not even sure who that was directed at, but I saw ONE thing. I tried hard to avoid seeing anything for some reason. What I saw towards the end of my days as a Satsang was a scene showing me the Truth had not been fully written yet. There’s a chapter that has not been put into words for humans to read just yet.

Of course, visions are projections of the mind just as dreams are but they often show the hidden things our worldly awake mind filters out.

Dreams, visions... the unfiltered mind. Yet not without merit. We live in the land of stories, songs, sounds and symbols.

Sonya thanks for your reply. Interesting to know. All the best to you in your journey. Just stay positive. 😊

Anon, what do you believe in? What are your thoughts related to Santmat?

Prolonged silence, year after year, by a participant or close associate to the participants in crime is a very powerful and informative statement. It means at least one and often several of these things...
1. I'm not helping you or anyone by choice.
2. I don't honor you or anyone who asks as sincere.
3. I don't honor my responsibility to you, the law or anyone else.
4.I'm guilty. I'm far more guilty than it looks.
5. I'm afraid of being blamed.
6. I don't want to accept responsibility unless I'm forced to by other people, with a higher morality than mine.
7. If others take all the blame, who got caught, and I can avoid taking my share of the blame that works for me.
8. I don't care who gets hurt.
9.I don't care if the other guilty parties go free.
10.I have no concern for any of the victims.
11. All that matters is me.

Silence over a prolonged period by a participant or close associate of participants in crime speaks loudly. It's a deafening statement: The final and conclusive evidence that proves all the other evidence.

Seeker that’s a pretty loaded question. 😊 I believe that the purpose of life is to realize our divine nature. Each one of us have the capacity to do that. No one is more special than the other. Masters throughout the ages come to bring our attention to that purpose. They awaken a desire in us to seek something greater. The journey on the path within however is in our own hands it’s all about our own effort. This is why the practice cannot be emphasized enough. All mystics tell us to go within whereas we are stuck on the outside and then we question many things and get confused. I know that all answers (not just on the path) but life and the universe can be found within.
Seeker I can go on and on but I think this is enough. 😊 good luck

"Inequality... and in the most intimate of relationships. "

In any measurable trait of humanity we're all unequal as races, genders and individuals. There is nothing tangible we can measure and arrive at equality.
Height,weight intelligence, aggressiveness, whatever. We're not equal. Way beyond humanity, nothing in existence is equal in any way.

Only in "spirituality" does equality even come into the picture. If you want to imaginarely live in a way where something so plainly non existent and fantastical is considered, you would actually do better being in a religious cult where we have equal souls.

Here on earth with our limited epistimological abilities, the one constant you will arrive at is inequality. As flawed as our ability is to even discern what is our isn't real, inequality remains everywhere at all times, and at all levels of this creation.

Dear Sonya,
I have to ask, where in Sant Mat did you get those ideas of sin, guilt and punishment? As I recall, Charan Singh often said that guilt was a useless emotion and the only punishment was to remain apart from our true home. Do simran and bhajan, and the rest will come automatically.

You here who keep saying there's overwhelming evidence against Gurinder, I have to wonder why you're not bothering to go to Petaluma next month to confront the guru, ask him questions, and also perhaps confront the sangat on their apathy or complicity. Sort of like this young woman does for Infowars: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=-m2aEZJGiBM

Year after year goes by with the blog talk about all the evils of RSSB, but no one will simply attend a Gurinder satsang Q&A to ask questions and make a statement.

This is the guru you say is making death threats and is guilty of egregious financial crimes. According to you, Gurinder is a menace. Why won't you go to Petaluma to protest, to demand answers?

@Jesse,
OK, to hell with idealism. Oh wait, I almost forgot, we’re already in hell. 😏

@anami,
I think those ideas came from the Sant Mat teachings that we have returned to this world multiple times and in many different life forms because of our karmas. I ask you, does a loving God appoint another “god” to judge souls and send them back to this world—this hell—over and over again so that they can “pay for their sins”? It’s flawed from the beginning. No forgiveness. No real justice either.

It’s a love story gone terribly wrong...

J, I guess you don't read this blog enough to keep up on the latest Gurinder Singh Dhillon developments. Someone did ask him about the financial fraud allegations last month, in Singapore. The guru's answer showed why there's no point in asking him again. I wrote a blog post about this:

https://hinessight.blogs.com/church_of_the_churchless/2019/04/rssb-guru-responds-to-allegations-of-criminality-weirdly.html

Here's what Dhillon was asked, and how he answered:

Q: Babaji: what do you have to say about the financial scandal?
A: RSSB has nothing to do with it. In case you want to read we have an article on the website.

Q: In case someone asks what should we say?
A: Tell him my baba was getting bored he needed some excitement and he came with a bang.

Q: Are you sure I say this?
A: Yes, it’s up to you whatever you want to believe.

Q: How come you have been silent on it and made no comments?
A: If I don’t tell you to react then how can I react.

Anon,
If you were in Singapore,
Please report what you saw and heard

Instead of just saying you were there.

I am beginning to agree that there is something fishy going on

@Sonya
I see, unfair from the get go. But what if we put "God" in quotation marks too? Then it's nothing personal.

Gurinder is innocent,

I’m a little confused... you seem to be suspicious of a person that is on your team.

No need to reply. Just found it curious.

''
I think those ideas came from the Sant Mat teachings that we have returned to this world multiple times and in many different life forms because of our karmas. I ask you, does a loving God appoint another “god” to judge souls and send them back to this world—this hell—over and over again so that they can “pay for their sins”? It’s flawed from the beginning. No forgiveness. No real justice either.''
..............................
This is my point too Sonya..when I was young it scared me to death.
It is not loving not fair..( from God) I found.

So it was a relieve to not ''be'' there,believe that stuff anymore.
In fact Babaji does not talk like that anymore as far as I know.
But he let satsang sewadars still tell the same stuff,at least a few years back I was there.
Babaji was sitting next to the speaker.
I showed my blech tongue to Babaji..
Later on I showed Babaji my sorry..ofcourse not about the stupid sewadar but about my ''behavier''
Actually I was happy to show my disgust about that stupid teaching.
The sewadar also talked ''We are the lucky once we are saved,not the ''others''..bbrr
It was good I showed my tongue..brrr
It had been nice if Babaji say something about that..
There is not much and surely not enough openess to''react,talk,doubd,discuss about this path.

Lets say,
it gets proven that He hhas been an accomplice in this web of legitimate or illegitimate transactions as it is being made out that He evaded a direct qquestions with distorted replies.

Will He be dethroned or can anyone .

In fact He is not the person in Chair with Worldly objectives neither have been seated on that humble pedestal by any Tom, Dick and Harry but by the dictat of His esteemed predecessors who at least were more docile and clear of any evildoings. Now to claim Him to be doubtful will in turn require the previous and consequently challenging the Saints of the past even of same order as well as they all have been groomed similarly and put to salvage the humanity out of this duality in similar ways and preachings.

Sonya
If someone claims to have been there (Anon) then it's just strange that he or she doesn't give their own version of events.

Why not be open and say what they witnessed instead of insisting that Brian has it all wrong but "I don't want to say what really was said"

sounds like nonsense

I am not on any team. I am open to change my mind as anyone who is genuine should be

I might change my name to Gurinder is not innocent.
who knows

I was there however like it said earlier this blog is not the place to discuss q and a from the Master. Like Ms. Gupta suggested for anyone who wants to know please attend and you will get your answers. The answers reported here are not accurate of what transpired. That’s all I’ll say rest is up to you.

Anon
Either set the record straight and say what you heard or let everyone carry on.
Unless you are going to give the correct version, you have no right to tell others to not speculate

What have you got to hide? You are anonymous so I don’t see what stops you stating the q&a as you heard it.

Nobody here cares who is Gupta or what she says.

Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Working...
Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been saved. Comments are moderated and will not appear until approved by the author. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.

Working...

Post a comment

Comments are moderated, and will not appear until the author has approved them.

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)

Welcome


  • Welcome to the Church of the Churchless. If this is your first visit, click on "About this site--start here" in the Categories section below.
  • HinesSight
    Visit my other weblog, HinesSight, for a broader view of what's happening in the world of your Church unpastor, his wife, and dog.
  • BrianHines.com
    Take a look at my web site, which contains information about a subject of great interest to me: me.
  • Twitter with me
    Join Twitter and follow my tweets about whatever.
  • I Hate Church of the Churchless
    Can't stand this blog? Believe the guy behind it is an idiot? Rant away on our anti-site.