Religion isn't all bad.
That was the not-so-surprising consensus at the monthly meeting of the Salon discussion group that my wife and I helped start up here in Salem about seventeen years ago.
The members are almost all godless Prius-driving, expresso-sipping, organic food-eating progressives like us.
Religiosity comes in for regular bashing, but since we're into open-mindedness and diversity, believers are embraced so long as they don't try to press their faith onto others.
Last night a woman talked about how much she liked taking some Christian children out to lunch at a fast food restaurant. She'd just met them. When they all sat down at a table, she noticed that nobody was starting to eat.
"We always say grace first," the oldest child explained. "Fine," our friend said. "Let's do it." The children formed a circle of hand-holding. Then one of them said three simple sincere sentences, thanking God for the food and other stuff I've forgotten.
This story led into a fairly lengthy group discussion of how rituals can be comforting and create a sense of community. However, nobody wanted to join a church just for ritualizing.
So the question became, "What sorts of rituals suit people who don't believe in God?"
A man talked about he used to live in a small Colorado town where residents had a wide variety of belief systems: Zen Buddhist, Christian, Jewish, Native American, Scientology, even SETI.
He and his wife would have dozens of diverse believers over for Thanksgiving dinner. Seated at a long homemade table, everyone would hold hands just as the children did.
But a period of silence would ensue, not words, so each person could do whatever inside their head. Including nothing, which is usually what I do during a moment of silence.
The discussion group members agreed that we humans need some rituals in our lives. Laurel, my wife, talked about how she's gotten into the habit of pausing before eating and taking several deep breaths with her eyes closed. This brings her into the culinary moment.
I said I'd just read in some book that a purpose of Zen'ish rituals, like the Japanese tea ceremony, is similar: to focus attention on the marvelous quality of what is present before us right now, right here.
It doesn't matter so much what that what is, I added, so long as the "ritual" (if that's even an appropriate word to use in this context) helps us appreciate the wonder of everyday existence.
At quality coffee houses they make my nonfat vanilla latte with this sort of flair. In a ceramic cup, a swirl of expresso on top of the foam, just so. I always look at it appreciatively before I take my first sip.
"This," I think, "is life as it's meant to be lived."
Which, I told the group, most likely is the only life we'll ever live, an afterlife being a decidedly chancy proposition. So each and every moment is almost (or precisely) infinitely precious.
Rituals that point us toward a transcendent imaginary divinity aren't as wonder-producing as godless rituals focused on the really real here-and-now, I said.
When attention is divided between this moment and a hypothesized heavenly better moment to come, which is the context of almost all religious rituals, we tend to lose sight of how marvelously special life is -- in all of its finitude.
If anyone wants to share their own favorite non-religious ritual, comment away. I'm always interested in hearing how the churchless worship without dogma, hierarchy, or blind belief.
...to me, Unitarian Universalism is exactly that...
Posted by: Alex | November 23, 2009 at 01:16 AM
It might be better for me to explain a little bit more.
To me, Unitarian Universalism (UU) is exactly a Godless church without dogma or blind belief doing Godless rituals for non-believers. UU, as the name hints, is certainly of Christian origin but, under the influence of religious humanism, they have removed all God-language from their hymns and rituals. Today, UU can be seen as a "church" (religious community) for religious humanists, freethinkers, atheists, etc. who value a shared religious life.
Posted by: Alex | November 23, 2009 at 06:29 PM
UU ?? i yawn.
Posted by: 1% | November 23, 2009 at 10:24 PM
Alex, UU is indeed a good example of a churchless church. Some relatives of my wife belong to a Unitarian group and enjoy it a lot. Plenty of open interesting discussion and fellowship.
I've been to a few Unitarian churches. They can be a bit too close to a traditional service for my taste, what with the choir, prayers, sermon, and such.
Still, I like the discussion groups, meditation classes, and the like. If the Unitarian church here in Salem was closer, and had its service at a more convenient time for me, I'd probably attend once in a while.
Posted by: Blogger Brian | November 24, 2009 at 12:01 AM
"I'm always interested in hearing how the churchless worship without dogma, hierarchy, or blind belief."
---So what is it that I need to worship in a churchless way? Let's work on that first before the need or no need for dogma, hierarchy, or blind belief.
Posted by: Roger | November 24, 2009 at 08:36 AM
Roger, what I meant by "worship" is what many people feel in a godless way: a sense of wonder, mystery, amazement when life is experienced as what it is (or at least seems to be).
A brief blip in a 14 billion year old universe. A short ride on a planet circling a star in a galaxy with several hundred billion other stars in a universe with several hundred billion similarly sized galaxies.
Here we are. Doing whatever we're doing. Not knowing where all this came from or where it is going, nor what will happen in the next moment.
It's a marvel. And that is what I was thinking of when I spoke about "worship."
Posted by: Blogger Brian | November 24, 2009 at 10:16 AM
Yes, the word worship could simply be replaced with wonder, mystery, or amazement.
With a healthy minimum of dogma, hierarchy or blind faith.
Posted by: Roger | November 25, 2009 at 07:14 AM