« Religious values have no place in politics | Main | Five books to support the churchless »

December 08, 2004


Feed You can follow this conversation by subscribing to the comment feed for this post.

You question why there has been no miracle so "grand, so out-of-the-ordinary, so impossible to disregard, that believers and unbelievers alike are left awestruck at this display of other-worldly power?"

I have been reading about a very fascinating phenomenon that took place outside of Cairo in Egypt that if true, seems to fit your description of a proper miracle.

Supposedly, a "Lady of Light" appeared on top of a Coptic Christian church during a period of three years 1968-1971. In the first days, the apparition occurred almost every night and on occasion lasted more than five hours. The mysterious light did not always have obvious features, but supposedly was obviously the form of a woman accompanied by "luminous doves" that flew in formation without flapping their wings.

The lady and the light show was clearly visible to everyone present Moslem, Catholic, Protestant, and non-believers. There were supposedly a number of miraculous cures too, but they're easy to dispute.

This "Lady" was seen by literally millions of people over that period of time.

What's up with that?

I'd love to say it's a hoax of some sort, but it's said to have been investigated and authenticated (as scientifically inexplicaple) by all the local, and national religious and even government authorities.

I'm actually hesitant to believe any of it mostly because you'd think one would have heard of such a thing if it were true.

Apparently, it made international headlines. The first apparition was April 2, 1968. There were a number of short books published about it.

Unfortunately, practically everthing I know about it is from the books reproduced on a web site.

It would be interesting to hear your comments, or the "other side" of the story if you know anything about it.

Your comments are interesting. In 1976 at a Church in Highland City, Florida. I witnessed a young lady wearing a club shoe getting prayer. Her foot was a full 4 to 5 inches shorter than the other. She walked away from the the church leaving the club shoe behind. I have never seen anthing like it before or since. Many in the church who have seen things like this have the same complaints you have listed. I have known people who have spent year after year of there lives, trying to capture some of the things you are talking about on film. The Living God seems to enjoy a good game of hide and seek. [email protected]

Eric, sorry for the delay in replying to your comment about the Cairo "lady of light." Poking around via Google, these visions of Mary do sound convincing. I've got an open mind as to their reality. If Mary, or any other saint, wants to pay me a visit, I hope she/he will do so.

That said, I found this extensive analysis of Marian apparitions quite interesting, though I admit I didn't read it word for word: http://www.orthodoxinfo.com/inquirers/marian_apparitions.aspx

My speed reading of the piece left me with the impression that the author finds some serious theological problems with such purported "miracles." For example, why does Mary appear by herself, without Jesus? And so on.

In a somewhat different sense, I too wonder why, if God is omnipotent, and omni-other stuff also, there is any doubt at all about His manifestations--either directly or via a substitute--on this Earth.

This article appeared in Psychology Today: http://cms.psychologytoday.com/articles/pto-19930101-000025.html It presents some possible explanations for phenomena such as those seen by people in Cairo. I don't know how viable the explanations are, but at least this shows that there are alternative ways of viewing "miracles" such as the one you cite.

Portugal's Lady of Fatima is a well-documented mass-witnessed miracle. It isn't so much that the children observed Mary and received divine command from her, it's that 50,000 pilgrims witnessed the moon turn into a bright silver disk that hovered about the now blood-red firmament. Trippy.

I've had something miraculous occur in my life. In college, I went through a find-myself phase. During the Summer, I was interning in the day and smoking pot in the woods at night. On top of being a math and computer science double major [yes, I'm a nerd], a former fulbright scholar and my former writing professor recommended that I read Aldous Huxley's Brave New World. I'd long had an interest in the illuminati, the rumored secret-society that is adamantly anti-religion. My interests were aroused by the book because the society of Brave New World is without the God meme, or idea of God, so it served as a model of what a Godless society might be like. Everyone is brain-washed to not believe in God. Moral education as a whole is gone. Science is everything, and what is valued as the desirable or the good is summed up well as incredible hedonism. Everybody's taking this designer-drug called soma and participating in lavish orgies. The society is utopian to some, dystopian to others, as a "savage" [or non-member of the society] finds out when he becomes a part of it and loses his sense of self... at any rate, in my thought, it was dystopian because i thought it to be an impossible end that justified bloody means [refer to Godless Marxism and its atrociously unsuccessful implementations... in fact, the book makes many references to communism and was written in the '30s]. Not only that, but I had an epiphany that without the idea of God or the God meme as it's called, morality really goes out the window [refer to the Divine Command Theory and Refutation of the Divine Command Theory]. I also considered how aforementioned Lady of Fatima's message was all about how atheist communism is bad for humankind. I thought about how in the Torah, the great flood followed humankind walking away from and sinning against God, wiping evil away and starting a new... Well, right as I thought about this a white dove landed next to me. Then I recalled how Noah used a dove to find out that the waters had receded. The skeptic that I am left to see if doves are endemic to New England [they are not] and considered the probability of the bird coming from a wedding or something. My cause and effect, empirical mind couldn't stand against my sense of wonder for the miraculous symbolism I'd observed.

If I didn't convey this experience clearly enough, I'll use Catholic Theology's definition of the spirit as an excuse: the sum of all inferential data on the world. Like a statistician might say, it's hard to summarize those data.

Us bible-thumpers tend to call those things revelations. I pray that one occurs for you, but I have a feeling that one will happen sooner if you really bust your ass in trying to figure out what it all means.

I liken a revelation to Michelangelo's painting of the Sistine chapel... Adam's arm is relaxed on his knee, its finger unexcitedly outstretched towards God's... God's finger straining to touch Adam's... a revelation a rare, brilliant, miraculous collision.

Since this [and revelation that followed shortly after], I've been reading the Torah and Kabbalah with some zeal. I pray that answers come to you, but more vigorously so that you come to answers.


PS, I was not smoking pot when I received my revelation. Burger King, not divine inspiration, usually follows ganja.

Asking James Randi to validate a purported ESP experience is like asking Oral Roberts to validate that evolution occurs. It violates the foundations of his world-view. Both are fundamentalists incapable of evaluating the evidence reasonably.

Here is scientific evidence for those who are able to reasonably look at evidence and don't already have their minds made up.


Verify your Comment

Previewing your Comment

This is only a preview. Your comment has not yet been posted.

Your comment could not be posted. Error type:
Your comment has been posted. Post another comment

The letters and numbers you entered did not match the image. Please try again.

As a final step before posting your comment, enter the letters and numbers you see in the image below. This prevents automated programs from posting comments.

Having trouble reading this image? View an alternate.


Post a comment

Your Information

(Name is required. Email address will not be displayed with the comment.)


  • Welcome to the Church of the Churchless. If this is your first visit, click on "About this site--start here" in the Categories section below.
  • HinesSight
    Visit my other weblog, HinesSight, for a broader view of what's happening in the world of your Church unpastor, his wife, and dog.
  • BrianHines.com
    Take a look at my web site, which contains information about a subject of great interest to me: me.
  • Twitter with me
    Join Twitter and follow my tweets about whatever.
  • I Hate Church of the Churchless
    Can't stand this blog? Believe the guy behind it is an idiot? Rant away on our anti-site.